Oils & Fats · 2 substitutes
Shortening Substitutes
Solid vegetable fat used for flaky pie crusts and tender cookies.
- 2
- Substitutes
- 4.5/5
- Avg quality
- 1
- Top-rated (5★)
- 5
- Use contexts
Best swap
The closest stand-in for Shortening is Coconut Oil (solid), used at 1:1 ratio and rated 5/5 across 5 cooking contexts.
- 5/5
- Coconut Oil (solid) - top pick
- 2
- tested substitutes
- 4.5/5
- average quality across all swaps
- 3
- dietary options covered
Across the 135 ingredients we track, the typical ingredient has about 3.6 documented substitutes.
Common uses for Shortening: pie crust, cookies, fried foods, biscuits, frosting. The best substitute usually depends on which of these functions, flavor, moisture, fat, binding, or leavening, you most need to preserve.
Every documented substitute for Shortening
Ranked by quality score (1–5, where 5 is virtually identical). Check the ratio and context tags before swapping, not every substitution is 1:1.
Best vegan shortening substitute. Use refined for neutral flavor. Works very well in pie crust.
Adds butter flavor. Pie crust will be slightly less flaky but more flavorful.
Where Shortening ranks for swap options
Number of documented substitutes per ingredient, across the whole database
2 Bottom 1% higher than 0% of 135 ingredients we track
Each bar is a band; taller bars hold more ingredients we track. The dashed line + filled bar mark this entry. Hover or tap any bar for its full count, share, and where it sits relative to this entry.
Source PlainSubstitute editorial database · July 2026
Quick comparison
| # | Substitute | Ratio | Quality |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Coconut Oil (solid) | 1:1 ratio | 5/5 |
| 2 | Butter | 1:1 ratio | 4/5 |
Choosing the right swap
Start with Coconut Oil (solid), then adjust for what your recipe needs.
- Match the substitute’s context tag to your recipe, a swap that shines in baking can fall flat in a sauce.
- Respect the listed ratio. Many swaps are not 1:1, and over- or under-dosing is the most common reason a substitution disappoints.
- Working around a diet? 3 of these options carry dietary tags, filter by your need. Browse by diet
- Need the opposite lookup? Browse other Oils & Fats ingredients with overlapping swaps. More Oils & Fats
Quality scores reflect overall similarity to the original; expect small differences in texture or colour even with top-rated swaps.